View Full Version : An Editor's Rant... *Grin*

August 12th, 2009, 11:01 AM
I've noticed a small trend in the publishing world. A rather dismaying one and one that I feel may be linked to the plethora of new places where you can publish, including but not limited to websites, CafePress, Lulu and of course the growing industry of e-book publishing.

For better or worse, there is a small subset of authors who are redefining (in their minds, anyway) the role of editor. Basically, the change that they are assuming can be summed up in one sentence.

The editor is there to catch and fix my mistakes.

On the surface, this does not sound bad. It actually sounds exactly correct. The problem is that the emphasis has changed. Most authors, whether born in 1950 or 1980 or at any other time, do feel that an editor's job is to catch mistakes. They are not wrong. The problem is this... a small subset of authors out there feel that it is the editors job to catch all the mistakes.

In other words, they don't don't worry about self-editing first. They just throw it out there and trust that someone else will check and double check. Some of this I blame on a lack of education, not in traditional schooling but in the craft of writing. Some of it I blame on the pressures of a growth market; where companies who are struggling to stay on the crest of a wave that will eventually break on the beach of maturity buy things to keep other companies from buying them first. And some of it I blame on the authors themselves, who have fallen prey to a cultural expectation that anything wrong must be able to be blamed on someone else.

It's sad really. And completely beyond my understanding. I can not personally conceive of turning in a work that was as rife with problems as some of things not only out there being edited, but even already published.

It has to stop somewhere. So, a word of warning. If I am your editor and you write about King George receiving a telegram of anger concerning the Boston Tea Party? Or if your African-American hero from the south side of Chicago constantly proclaims things to be "bloody annoying" and no one finds it strange? Or if your baseball player hits eighty home runs in 2004 and never has to deal with a steroid accusation and never gets interrupted at dinner for an autograph request and can easily hide that he is actually an alien from Arcturus Prime complete with a tail that somehow never got noticed by teammates or the ESPN reporters in the locker room?

Expect me to call you on it.

You can use Google as easily as I. You can look up when the telegraph was invented, or the year Germany invaded Poland. And you know that a kid from Chicago will use the F word and a thinly disguised Mr. Darby clone in Victorian England will not.

As your editor, I am there to help you change there into their or point out that the brown sweater was red three pages ago. I have no problem with things like that. We all lose track of things over the course of months writing a book. I'm not perfect. I screw up,too. All the time actually. Both as an author and as an editor. But even so...

As an editor,it is not my job to do your homework. It is not my job to do your basics. It is my job to tweak and prod and try to help you be the best you can possibly be. I am not supposed to build the engine. Just tune it up. That's why I get one-tenth the royalty percentage you do. Because you are supposed to have already done the big job. I'm supposed to help with the details... and maybe keep you off Twitter's #romfail.

Kim Smith
August 12th, 2009, 03:44 PM
Well said!! Thanks for saying it too!

August 12th, 2009, 05:52 PM
:notworthy: bends and kisses Mr. Belegon's feet.

I have the ambition to be an editor but as a reviewer I know how many books have basic mistakes that should have been picked up and i believe that if editors didn't have as many problems to fix as they do most of these mistakes wouldn't be missed.
Yes this is a pet peeve of mine and, for anyone who doesn't already know me, as a reviewer if you make a major mistake such expecting the UK to be the same as the US( my biggest pet peeve). I will also call you on it I will put it in my review and i won't give you 5 cups. Mr Belegon is right it is teh authors job to do the research, an editors job to tweek and a reviewers job to say how well it was all done.

Ok i'll get off my soap box and take myself to bed i'm falling asleep at the laptop again.

August 12th, 2009, 08:56 PM
Thank you Kim!

...and Hollie, I am beginning to believe we need more intelligent people on their soapbox. After all, the stupid ones don't seem to have any trouble getting up and screaming from theirs...