Actually, Dani, they give more 4's than you might think, but the 4 1/2's are very scarce. In the most recent magazine (I got mine today), there are 30 Historical Romance reviews and only 8 4 1/2's. The majority of them are 4's. Both The Marquis and The Importance of Almack's got 4's, so I'm just tickled pink to get that 4 1/2 - and to see what great company I'm in.